Review of ‘The Whispering Dark’

The Whispering Dark follows Delaney, a deaf girl, into the dark, deadly, and supernatural school of Godbole University.

The Whispering Dark had a lot of promise. Unfortunately, this book was a chaotic mess.

Poorly Written Characters

The one thing that bothered me here was the romance between Delaney and Colton. It wasn’t even that he was rude to her, but for a girl who didn’t want to be seen as weak due to her deafness, her constant need to gain his approval was bothersome.

It just didn’t sit with who her character was.

This is a girl who, at first, appears to be headstrong. She wants to live, really live. Her parents coddled her all her life and treated her like glass, but she is stronger than that and seeks to prove it.

So her desperate need to attach herself to this guy who wants nothing to do with her didn’t fit with the story or the way the character began. It just didn’t make sense.

Then there is Colton, who is a prick. Nothing about him shines off the pages. He’s just a guy. He’s a name on a page that doesn’t begin to shine until the last quarter of the book. Of course, the reader has to make it to that point.

Which leads me to the story. The Whispering Dark could not decide what it wanted to be. I generally love when authors blend genres together because it makes for a good story, provided it is done well.

Messy Blend of Genres

Unfortunately, it was poorly executed. This blends horror, supernatural, paranormal, and science fiction. I didn’t understand what the story was trying to be.

Delaney can talk to the dead. I’m also willing to bet she can bring the dead back to life. Colton can travel between universes and even bring people with him. In the space between the universes, the dead live. This is the space where Andrews makes it seem like Demons live.

All those elements are interesting. Unfortunately, the story lacks cohesion. It does not blend together the genres, instead leaving the reader confused.

The other biggest issue this novel had was the fluidity. It wasn’t always clear who was talking to whom, which was very irritating. I would go back sentences and trace who was talking just so I knew what was happening in the scene. Again, this connects to the issue with Delaney. The characters did not always sound like themselves. They sounded like entirely different characters, sometimes making following the dialogue tiresome. It ruined the flow of the story and set up a jarring pace.

Final Thoughts

There are so many things wrong with The Whispering Dark. This novel was a struggle because I could not connect to the characters, the plot, or the overall storytelling. It lacked cohesion and fluidity.

Rating: 1.5 out of 5.

Like this review?

Don’t forget to follow Cyn’s Workshop on Facebook | Instagram | TikTok Twitter | Tumblr | Spotify | YouTubeBookBub | GoodreadsLinkedIn to stay tuned for future reviews.

Become a Supporter

Buy Me A Coffee

Donate with Paypal

Help Cyn’s Workshop improve and grow with a one-time donation. Donations go towards equipment, writing suppliments and giveaways to the bookish community.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.