Prince of Morning Review: A Haunting Historical Fantasy with Ghosts, Gods, and Unexpected Romance

A haunting historical fantasy set in 1880s New York, Prince of Morning blends ghostly mysteries, immortal gods, and emotional romance into a captivating supernatural adventure.


Sometimes the best reading experiences come from books you pick up without knowing much about them. Prince of Morning by Jen Bennett turned out to be exactly that kind of surprise. What initially appears to be a traditional fantasy quickly reveals itself as a blend of historical fiction, supernatural mystery, and mythological romance set in 1880s New York. The result is a story that slowly pulls you in with eerie atmosphere, compelling characters, and an emotional romance at its core.

A Nurse Who Sees the Dead

The story follows Molly Ren, an eighteen-year-old Irish immigrant studying nursing in New York City. Molly has a secret ability sheโ€™s always treated as normal: she can see and speak with ghosts.

Her constant companion is Bethany, a former classmate who died after receiving too much morphine during an illness. Beth doesnโ€™t even fully realize sheโ€™s dead, and the dynamic between her and Molly creates some of the bookโ€™s most engaging moments. Bethany is witty, persistent, and fiercely loyal, and her presence adds both humor and emotional depth to the story.

Mollyโ€™s unusual gift catches the attention of Charles Voss, a wealthy and mysterious patient suffering from tuberculosis. When he requests Molly personally to care for him at his isolated mansion, she reluctantly agreesโ€”only to discover that the estate is filled with occult secrets.

A Prisoner in the Basement

While working at the mansion, Molly discovers something far more disturbing than ghosts wandering the halls: a man chained in the basement.

That man is Nim, an immortal being known as the Prince of Morningโ€”one of the sons of Death whose role is to comfort those grieving the loss of loved ones. Despite being a godlike figure, Nim is somehow imprisoned and injured, which should be impossible for someone like him.

That man is Nim, an immortal being known as the Prince of Morningโ€”one of the sons of Death whose role is to comfort those grieving the loss of loved ones. Despite being a godlike figure, Nim is somehow imprisoned and injured, which should be impossible for someone like him.

Mythology and Mystery

One of the most interesting elements of the novel is the mythology surrounding Nim and his origins. The story hints at disturbing and tragic beginnings for these immortal beings, adding a darker tone beneath the romantic fantasy surface.

The mythology unfolds gradually through Nimโ€™s perspective and conversations with Molly. While the book never fully reveals every detail, the glimpses we do get are unique and unsettling in the best way.

Romance and Emotional Investment

The romance between Molly and Nim develops slowly as they work together to unravel the mystery surrounding the mansion. Their relationship balances humor, vulnerability, and growing trust.

What makes the romance particularly effective is how emotionally invested it becomes by the end of the story. The question of whether an immortal god and a mortal woman could ever truly be together raises the stakes in a meaningful way.

Without giving too much away, the ending delivers a satisfying emotional payoff that suggests hope for their futureโ€”even if their paths arenโ€™t immediately clear.

Final Thoughts

Prince of Morning is a surprisingly compelling blend of historical fantasy, supernatural mystery, and mythological romance. The eerie atmosphere, engaging side characters, and unique mythology help the story stand out, while the emotional connection between Molly and Nim keeps the pages turning.

Even readers who are hesitant about historical fantasy may find themselves pleasantly surprised by how immersive and character-driven this story becomes.

Rating: 4 out of 5.



Like this review?

Don’t forget to follow Cyn’s Workshop on Facebook | Instagram | TikTok Twitter | Tumblr | Spotify | YouTubeBookBub | GoodreadsLinkedIn to stay tuned for future reviews.


Become a Supporter

Buy Me A Coffee

Donate with Paypal

Help Cyn’s Workshop improve and grow with a one-time donation. Donations go towards equipment, writing suppliments and giveaways to the bookish community.

$1.00

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.