The Escape Game Review: A Twisty, Addictive YA Mystery Thriller

The Escape Game by Marissa Meyer and Tamara Moss completely surprised me! With relentless pacing, four distinct perspectives, deadly escape room challenges, and a murder mystery that kept me guessing until the very end, this YA thriller is an addictive, character-driven adventure.


Sometimes the best books are the ones you never would have picked up for yourself. That’s exactly what happened when I read The Escape Game by Marissa Meyer and Tamara Moss. I received an advance reader copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review, and while I was excited to see Marissa Meyer’s name attached to the project, I wasn’t entirely sure whether this book would be for me.

If you’ve followed my reviews for any length of time, you know that I primarily gravitate toward fantasy and science fiction. Give me an epic fantasy with complicated mythology, magical creatures, and immersive worldbuilding, and I’m a happy reader. Mystery thrillers, on the other hand, aren’t usually the first books I reach for.

But that’s one of the reasons I love receiving ARCs from publishers. Sometimes they encourage me to step outside my comfort zone and discover something I might otherwise overlook.

And let me tell you, I’m so glad I gave this book a chance.

The Escape Game was an incredibly entertaining, fast-paced mystery thriller filled with clever puzzles, shocking twists, and a cast of characters I absolutely adored. The pacing was relentless, the mystery kept me guessing, and the character development gave the story an emotional foundation that made it so much more than a competition thriller.

Honestly, I had a blast reading it.

My Love for Marissa Meyer’s Books

Before getting into the review, I have to talk about my love for Marissa Meyer because she’s one of those authors whose books have practically taken over my shelves.

I absolutely love The Lunar Chronicles. In fact, I love that series so much that I own three different editions: the original paperbacks, the FairyLoot editions, and the Bookish Box editions.

Yes, three editions.

Listen, we all have our weaknesses, and apparently mine is collecting beautiful editions of books I love.

I’ve also read Gilded and Cursed, both of which I thoroughly enjoyed, and Heartless remains one of those books that emotionally destroyed me in the best possible way.

Seriously, if you haven’t read Heartless, you need to. That Queen of Hearts retelling still breaks my heart whenever I think about it.

Despite loving Meyer’s fantasy novels, I haven’t read everything she’s written. I still need to get to Renegades and The House Saphir, and I haven’t explored her contemporary romances.

That’s primarily because I tend to prioritize fantasy when buying books. I usually purchase stories that I already know appeal to my reading preferences, especially considering how expensive collecting books can become.

So even though I love Marissa Meyer, The Escape Game probably wouldn’t have been an automatic purchase for me.

Which would have been a shame, because this book was fantastic.

Survivor Meets Escape Rooms

One of the things that immediately hooked me was the premise.

Imagine a reality competition similar to Survivor, except instead of competing in traditional physical challenges, contestants must navigate elaborate escape rooms filled with dangerous puzzles and increasingly complicated obstacles.

Now add a murder mystery.

That’s essentially the experience The Escape Game delivers, and I absolutely loved it.

The escape room challenges create a fantastic foundation for the story because they naturally generate suspense. Every puzzle introduces another obstacle, and the contestants have to rely on their intelligence, creativity, and teamwork to survive the competition.

But there’s more happening than simply trying to win.

The contestants are also dealing with secrets, personal insecurities, and the possibility that someone connected to the competition is responsible for a murder.

That combination of physical challenges and psychological tension made the story incredibly engaging.

I loved how the escape rooms weren’t simply decorative elements added to make the premise sound interesting. They were an essential part of the narrative, constantly pushing the characters into situations where they had to think quickly and learn to trust one another.

Sierra’s Return and the Murder of Angelica

At the center of the mystery is Sierra, a former contestant whose previous experience on the show ended in tragedy.

During the final episode of her original season, her sister Angelica was discovered murdered inside a coffin.

And Sierra became the prime suspect in the eyes of the public.

Now, she’s returning to the competition, determined to discover who actually killed her sister and clear her name.

I thought this was an excellent way to establish the mystery because Sierra isn’t simply investigating a murder from the outside. She’s returning to the very environment connected to her sister’s death, surrounded by people who already have opinions about her guilt.

That creates an enormous amount of emotional tension.

Sierra knows she didn’t kill Angelica, but convincing other people of her innocence is another matter entirely. Even some of her teammates initially struggle to trust her because of the accusations surrounding her sister’s murder.

I appreciated that the story didn’t immediately resolve those suspicions. Instead, Sierra has to gradually develop relationships with people who aren’t entirely sure what to believe about her.

And that process becomes one of the most rewarding parts of the novel.

Four Perspectives, Four Distinct Personalities

One of my favorite aspects of The Escape Game was its use of four different points of view.

Multiple perspectives can sometimes become overwhelming, particularly when the characters don’t have sufficiently distinct personalities. I’ve read plenty of novels where I struggled to remember whose chapter I was reading because everyone sounded exactly the same.

Thankfully, that wasn’t a problem here.

Each character has a recognizable personality, individual motivations, and personal insecurities that influence how they approach the competition.

I loved that the cast felt genuinely diverse in both identity and personality, including transgender representation and characters of color. More importantly, the characters weren’t defined solely by those aspects of their identities. They had their own emotional struggles, secrets, and reasons for participating in the competition.

The shifting perspectives also allowed me to understand how differently each contestant interpreted the same situations.

Some characters were more suspicious, while others were willing to trust their teammates. Some approached the challenges with confidence, while others struggled with fear and insecurity.

That variety made the group dynamics considerably more interesting, especially as the competition became increasingly dangerous.

Sierra’s Grumpy Personality Made Her Even Better

Sierra was one of the characters I found particularly compelling because she has a somewhat grumpy, emotionally guarded personality.

Considering everything she’s experienced, that makes complete sense.

She’s been accused of murdering her sister, she’s carrying an enormous amount of grief, and she’s returned to a competition that represents one of the most traumatic experiences of her life.

Naturally, she’s not particularly eager to open herself up to strangers.

But that’s what makes her character development so satisfying.

As the story progresses, Sierra gradually begins forming genuine connections with her teammates. They start recognizing that she’s more than the accusations surrounding her, while Sierra begins allowing herself to trust people again.

I loved watching those emotional barriers slowly come down because the story never suggests that friendship can instantly erase grief or trauma.

Instead, it shows how meaningful relationships can provide support during incredibly difficult experiences.

And there’s one scene in particular that absolutely won me over.

The Freezer Scene Was Everything

I have to talk about the freezer scene because it was one of my favorite moments in the entire book.

At one point, the characters find themselves trapped in a freezer, facing the very real possibility that they might die.

Naturally, emotions are running high.

But instead of allowing the situation to completely destroy their morale, the group begins opening up to one another. There’s this wonderfully emotional moment where they essentially tell Sierra that they’ll be her family.

And I loved it.

Here’s this emotionally guarded character who’s spent so much time keeping people at a distance, suddenly surrounded by teammates who genuinely care about her.

Then we have Ari, who is understandably panicking about their situation.

While everyone else is trying to gather together, he’s worried about the fact that they’re sitting on the floor of a freezing room and might literally die.

And honestly? Fair point, Ari.

The entire exchange was hilarious because it balanced genuine emotional vulnerability with humor that felt completely natural to the characters.

Eventually, Ari joins the group, and the moment becomes this wonderful example of how much their relationships have developed.

I absolutely adored that scene because it captured everything I loved about the characterization.

Found Family Done Right

One of the strongest elements of The Escape Game was the found-family dynamic.

Every character enters the competition carrying personal baggage, and nearly everyone is hiding something.

Some of those secrets are connected to their insecurities, while others have more significant implications for the relationships developing within the group.

What I appreciated was how the characters responded when those secrets were eventually revealed.

Rather than immediately abandoning one another or allowing every revelation to destroy their friendships, they generally approached those moments with understanding.

There were definitely feelings of frustration, especially when someone realized a teammate hadn’t been entirely honest. But those emotions didn’t automatically erase the trust they had already developed.

Instead, the characters recognized that everyone had their reasons for keeping certain things private.

I thought that was a wonderful approach because it allowed the friendships to feel mature and meaningful.

They didn’t have to agree with every decision someone made to continue caring about them.

And I loved watching them gradually become a team that genuinely supported one another.

Secrets, Suspicion, and Character Development

Of course, the fact that everyone is hiding something also creates fantastic suspense.

As readers, we’re constantly learning new information about the contestants, which naturally raises questions about their motivations.

Why did they enter the competition? What are they trying to accomplish? And how much of what they’re telling their teammates is actually true?

I appreciated that the secrets weren’t simply there to create unnecessary drama.

Instead, they helped reveal different aspects of the characters’ personalities and experiences.

When someone finally shared something they’d been hiding, it often provided additional context for their earlier behavior.

That made the characterization feel layered because the characters weren’t immediately revealing everything about themselves.

We were discovering who they were alongside their teammates.

And as those relationships developed, the group became increasingly determined to accomplish two things: uncover the truth about Angelica’s murder and win the competition.

Because apparently solving a murder isn’t enough.

They also have an escape game to conquer.

And I loved that energy.

The Escape Room Puzzles Were Incredibly Immersive

Now, let’s talk about the escape rooms themselves because I was completely invested.

I love when a book incorporates puzzles that encourage readers to participate in the mystery rather than simply watching the characters solve everything.

And The Escape Game absolutely delivered on that front.

There was one particular puzzle involving a message written backward, and I was so determined to understand the clue that I actually pulled out my phone.

I took a picture of the page and flipped the image so I could read the message properly.

Because apparently, I didn’t have the patience to sit there trying to decipher backward text.

I needed answers immediately.

That’s how invested I was in the story.

I wasn’t simply reading about the characters solving puzzles. I wanted to participate in the experience myself, which made the escape room challenges considerably more entertaining.

And I think that’s one of the novel’s greatest strengths.

The puzzles create an interactive feeling that makes readers want to engage with the mystery alongside the contestants.

Relentless Pacing That Never Lets Up

Another thing I absolutely loved was the pacing.

This book moves.

Between the escape room challenges, shifting perspectives, character secrets, and murder investigation, there’s always something happening to maintain the tension.

But despite how quickly the story progresses, I never felt like the character development was being sacrificed.

The quieter moments between challenges allow the contestants to form relationships and reveal different aspects of their personalities, while the competition itself constantly pushes them into new conflicts.

That balance was incredibly effective.

I loved that the tension wasn’t limited to the murder mystery. There was also suspense surrounding whether the characters would complete each challenge, whether they could trust one another, and whether their secrets would eventually undermine their teamwork.

The result was a novel that felt consistently engaging from beginning to end.

I genuinely struggled to put it down because I always wanted to know what would happen next.

A Murder Mystery That Completely Fooled Me

One of the reasons I don’t read mystery thrillers as frequently as fantasy is that I sometimes have a habit of trying to solve the mystery before the characters do.

And honestly, I don’t always want that.

Sometimes I want to be surprised.

I want to reach the final revelation and realize that the author has been carefully misleading me the entire time.

Unfortunately, when a mystery becomes too predictable, I sometimes lose interest because I’ve already figured out where the story is going.

Thankfully, The Escape Game kept me guessing.

I had absolutely no idea who murdered Angelica.

None.

When the truth was finally revealed, I was completely stunned.

I was looking in one direction when I should have been looking somewhere entirely different, and the revelation hit me like a ton of bricks.

What made the twist especially effective was that it still made sense within the context of the story.

It wasn’t simply a random revelation introduced for shock value.

The clues were there, but they were subtle enough that I didn’t recognize their significance while reading.

And even looking back afterward, I genuinely don’t think I would have figured it out.

That’s exactly what I want from a murder mystery.

The Plot Twists Were Brilliantly Executed

The final murder revelation wasn’t the only twist that caught me off guard.

Throughout the novel, Meyer and Moss introduce developments that repeatedly challenge readers’ assumptions about the characters and the competition.

I loved how the story kept redirecting my attention.

Just when I thought I understood what was happening, another revelation would force me to reconsider everything.

And the best part was that those twists didn’t feel disconnected from the larger narrative.

They contributed to the tension while also revealing important information about the characters and their motivations.

I think that’s what separates an effective mystery from one that simply relies on shocking readers.

A good twist should surprise you, but it should also make sense once the truth is revealed.

And The Escape Game accomplishes that beautifully.

A Satisfying Mystery with More Story to Tell

One thing I appreciated was that the novel provides answers to its central murder mystery.

By the end of the book, we discover who killed Angelica, and that particular storyline reaches a satisfying conclusion.

However, the novel also leaves room for the story to continue.

There’s a lingering sense that the characters’ experiences aren’t entirely over, and the ending sets up possibilities for another installment.

I liked that balance because I didn’t feel cheated out of the answers I’d spent the entire book waiting for.

The murder mystery was resolved, but there was still enough intrigue to make me curious about what might happen next.

And considering how much I enjoyed the characters, I’m absolutely interested in continuing their story.

I’m especially curious about how the group dynamic will evolve after everything they’ve experienced together.

They’ve already survived dangerous escape rooms, uncovered secrets, and investigated a murder.

At this point, I feel like they’ve earned a vacation.

Preferably somewhere without locked doors.

Why I Love Receiving Unexpected ARCs

Reading The Escape Game reminded me why I enjoy receiving advance copies from publishers.

When I’m buying books for myself, I tend to stick to genres and authors I already know I enjoy.

And honestly, that makes sense.

Books are expensive, and when you’re building a personal library, you want to invest in stories that genuinely interest you.

We’re book dragons.

Our books are our hoard.

And we’re very protective of that hoard.

But receiving ARCs gives me an opportunity to explore books I might otherwise overlook.

Sometimes those experiments don’t work out, but other times I discover something absolutely fantastic.

This was definitely one of those times.

In fact, I enjoyed The Escape Game so much that I’m keeping my ARC.

I usually pass along many of my advance copies to members of my book clubs, but this one is staying on my shelves.

That’s how much I enjoyed it.

I was even excited when someone purchased a copy while I was working because I immediately wanted to tell them how good it was.

And honestly, that’s one of the best feelings as a bookseller and reviewer.

Final Thoughts

The Escape Game by Marissa Meyer and Tamara Moss was an incredibly entertaining YA mystery thriller that completely exceeded my expectations.

I loved the reality competition premise, particularly how the escape room challenges created constant suspense while encouraging readers to engage with the puzzles themselves.

The four perspectives were also wonderfully executed. Every character had a distinct personality, individual insecurities, and secrets that gradually became important to the larger story.

But what truly made the novel stand out was the found-family dynamic.

Watching Sierra and her teammates develop genuine friendships while navigating the competition and investigating Angelica’s murder gave the story an emotional depth that I wasn’t expecting.

I especially appreciated how the characters generally responded to one another’s secrets with understanding rather than immediately abandoning their relationships.

And then there’s the murder mystery.

I genuinely did not see that ending coming.

The authors completely fooled me, but the final revelation still made sense within the context of the story. That’s exactly the kind of twist I love because it leaves me surprised without making the mystery feel unfair.

The pacing was relentless, the characterization was fantastic, and the escape room challenges were so immersive that I actually found myself solving puzzles alongside the characters.

Ultimately, this was a wonderful reminder that stepping outside my usual reading preferences can lead to some incredible discoveries.

If you enjoy escape rooms, reality competition stories, found-family dynamics, and murder mysteries with shocking twists, I highly recommend giving this one a chance.

ARC Disclosure: I received an advance reader copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.



Like this review?

Don’t forget to follow Cyn’s Workshop on Facebook | Instagram | TikTok | Twitter | Tumblr | Spotify | YouTube | BookBub | Goodreads | LinkedIn to stay tuned for future reviews.


Become a Supporter

Buy Me A Coffee

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.